> The best depends on your particular usage and types of content. And
> whether you have a CF slot SD slot or both. I think the X5 has both?
[quoted text clipped - 60 lines]
> >
> > I'm using a dell axim x5.
Not really any brand preference here. I have a PCMCIA CF Card adapter
that was meant to adapt a CF card Bluetooth adapter to a laptop. Works
great as a reader and seems to be faster than USB 1.1 at least. I use
this with a notebook simply for convenience. No USB cable. But I also
have a 5-in-1 combo usb2.0 unit that will work with CF, SD and other
cards I currently don't use. Just make sure you know it's mb limit. A
lot of stuff has nothing marked on the package so either be sure of what
it is from info you find on the vendors/manufacturers website, or buy it
locally from someone who has a liberal return policy. I won't buy any
media card based products off a website unless I demo one first at a
bricks and mortar shop, because most are not up front about their memory
card limitations. This is probably more of a problem these days with
specific devices others than simple card readers. Not sure. One other
feature you will want is an activity light. You don't want to be pulling
out cards while the device is still writing or you will have to reformat
the card. Or possible ruin it.
They are fairly simple devices so I don't know how much brand means as
far as quality goes. I generally stay away from unknown brands but would
probably buy this type of device with any commonly known brand stamped
on it. Some may be faster than others but the limitation is usually in
the bus. I haven't heard of anyone having problems with any particular
brand so it may not be worth paying more for a name.
Style...size...color...memory capacity limit....whatever floats your
boat. Most USB readers are USB2.0 compliant now, I would suggest that
even if you currently have only USB1.1 machines.
> Is there a certain card reader that you would recommend?
If you have to put it into a floppy drive to transfer to a PC stay away
from it. It is probably painfully slow. The most common are USB. I would
suggest that for most, since they are cheap and highly portable, unless
you want one solely for a laptop and want the convenience of a pcmcia
based solution. Multi format readers are the way to go but a floppy
interface is berry berry bad.
> I've researched some and am looking at one that reads 7 different formats
> and is a 3 1\2 inch floppy drive as well.
>
> This way I can still use it if I change card types.
RanMan - 28 Dec 2003 19:44 GMT
I've found a 3.5 drive that supports the following:
Supports 6 Types of Flash Memory Card: Compact Flash, MicroDrive, Secure
Digital Card, MultiMedia Card, MemoryStick, SmartMedia. 3.5 Floppy Disk
Drive. OS Support: Windows 98 SE, 2000, Me, XP, Mac OS 8.6 or higher. Plug +
Play: No Driver Installation required for Windows 2000(*2), ME,XP, Mac OS
8.6 or higher. LED indicator: For Power and Access. USB Powered: No extra
power supply required. Fast Transfer Rate: 500Kb/s Max(FDD), 12Mb/s
Max(Memory Card). USB 2.0 Full Speed Compliant. Backwards compatible with
USB 1.0 &1.1: Use your USB Media Drive with USB 1.1 or 1.0 computer ports.
I'm not sure of the speed of the typical FDD, do you know?
> Not really any brand preference here. I have a PCMCIA CF Card adapter
> that was meant to adapt a CF card Bluetooth adapter to a laptop. Works
[quoted text clipped - 36 lines]
> >
> > This way I can still use it if I change card types.
David - 29 Dec 2003 01:56 GMT
Sounds like you are talking about a media reader that fits fits into an
empty 3.5 in drive bay. Is this correct?
If so those are nice. From the specs it looks like the card reader ties
into the USB bus which is the norm. The only disadvantage would be it is
not portable but they are great if you don't need that. No external cables!
The FDD speed shouldn't matter. They are just providing a standard 3.5
in. drive also, but the media readers tie into the USB BUS.
If the price is right and you don't want a media reader that you can
plug into more than a single machine go for it.
> I've found a 3.5 drive that supports the following:
>
[quoted text clipped - 8 lines]
>
> I'm not sure of the speed of the typical FDD, do you know?
RanMan - 29 Dec 2003 12:23 GMT
My plan is to buy this style of reader configuration with the 3.5 ability
and take my existing 3.5 and put into another system 'cause I need another
3.5 anyway. I don't not portability and have too many cables already.
Thanks.
> Sounds like you are talking about a media reader that fits fits into an
> empty 3.5 in drive bay. Is this correct?
[quoted text clipped - 20 lines]
> >
> > I'm not sure of the speed of the typical FDD, do you know?